Corporate Farming: A Reasonable Hope of Fairness

August 2010

On June 22, 2010, USDA published a new draft rule regarding how meatpacking corporations must deal with farmers and ranchers in the procurement of livestock and poultry. It's not perfect, but it is the most aggressive livestock market reform to come out of Washington since the passage of the Packers and Stockyards Act itself. The rule will breathe some life and some competition back into our livestock markets.

The administrative rule covers a number of reforms to help restore competition and contract fairness to livestock and poultry markets, including establishing a definition for what constitutes an “undue or unreasonable preference.” The Packers and Stockyards Act specifically prohibits price discrimination by meatpackers against smaller volume, family farm and ranch livestock producers. Specifically, the Act makes it unlawful for packers to “make or give any undue or unreasonable preference or advantage to any particular person or locality in any respect whatsoever.”

The Center for Rural Affairs is working hard to improve USDA’s unreasonable preference rule, and we’ll fight – tooth and nail – to ensure that the packers and their commodity group allies cannot weaken it.

USDA’s draft rule is actually several rulemaking efforts in one. This article deals almost exclusively with the “undue or unreasonable preference” sections of the rule. Visit www.cfra.org/competition for more information on the rulemaking process, how to comment, and our detailed analysis. You’ll also find links to perspectives on other aspects of the rule from the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, Western Organization of Resource Councils, R-CALF and others.

Improvements to the Draft Rule
USDA’s draft rule needs to be improved in three areas:

First, and foremost, the rule does not specifically disallow purely volume-based premiums.
Moreover, the unreasonable preference sections focus excessively on treatment of large-volume livestock producers in relation to “groups of producers” at the expense of individual, small-volume producers.
Last, the draft rule fails to exclude premiums that are based on nebulous, shadowy, so-called “operational efficiencies” that packers claim occur within the confines of the plant versus real and verifiable differences in transactional costs related to procuring and handling livestock outside the plant door.

USDA has not effectively enforced the Packers and Stockyards Act for decades. For example, packers routinely pay five or six cents per pound – more in some cases – in purely volume-based premiums to the largest hog producers just because they are large. These sweetheart deals for large-volume producers have become commonplace, but no less a violation of law.

Six cents per pound may not sound like much of a discount, but, for a family farmer with 150 sows in a farrow-to-finish operation it amounts to receiving $56,000 less annually for hogs of the same quality, simply because he or she markets fewer hogs. That’s what this rule needs to put an end to. That’s what we set out to accomplish when we worked so diligently to include an “unreasonable preference” rulemaking provision in the Livestock Title of the 2008 Farm Bill.

Giving credit where it is due, Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack and GIPSA Director Dudley Butler had the courage to take that farm bill provision and run with it, resulting in a strong step in the right direction. Also, their draft rule correctly establishes that while actions by packers that damage competition in the sector are always violations of the “unreasonable preference” provision, the occurrence of competitive injury is not necessary for a violation to occur. USDA should stand their ground on this point.

What You Can Do to Finish the Job
It is absolutely crucial that USDA receive comments from as many family farmers and ranchers as possible, as well as everyone interested in making livestock markets more competitive and livestock production more economically, environmentally and socially sustainable. It’s a strong rule, which means the packers and their minions are going to whine and complain heartily. USDA needs to hear from the rest of us too, if we want to keep the rule strong and improve it along the way.

Please look here for more information on this rulemaking process, including the Center for Rural Affairs’ detailed comments and analysis, a copy of the draft rule and information about how to submit comments to USDA. If you need any assistance with writing and submitting comments, contact John Crabtree, johnc@cfra.org or 402.687.2100.

USDA has extended the period for accepting public comments on the draft rule. Comments are now due by November 22, 2010 instead of August 22.

Comments

USDA Rules on Meatpackers

Tue, 08/10/2010 - 11:14 — Carla Wilhite (not verified)

I am not a farmer, but am a consumer of farm products. I firmly support strengthening the rules for the meatpackers and stockyards act, and eliminating any loopholes that allow them to give price preferences to large corporate businesses over small farmers and ranchers. It's worth paying more at the supermarket if it means being fair to the families who produce our food. Carla

USDA Rules on Meatpackers

Wed, 09/07/2011 - 13:58 — Carla Brown (not verified)

Carla Wilhite, I agree with you 100%! Carla

I second that. Nice

Thu, 09/29/2011 - 13:44 —

I second that. Nice sentiments Carla. genf20 review

Also, their draft rule

Thu, 11/24/2011 - 08:38 — eavedrop44 (not verified)

Also, their draft rule correctly establishes that while actions by packers that damage competition in the sector are always violations of the “unreasonable preference” provision, the occurrence of competitive injury is not necessary for a violation to occur. USDA should stand their ground on this point. colouring pages

It’s a strong rule, which

Sun, 12/25/2011 - 19:20 — eavedrop44 (not verified)

It’s a strong rule, which means the packers and their minions are going to whine and complain heartily. USDA needs to hear from the rest of us too, if we want to keep the rule strong and improve it along the way.wholesale ladies clothing

Also like to thanks for this

Tue, 01/17/2012 - 04:36 — sahab12 (not verified)

Also like to thanks for this real nice and informatic blog - hope you get some more interested informations in future! Will be nice to visit this side more times. Schwimmbadüberdachung

Rules needed to ensure fair practice from big supermarkets

Sun, 09/18/2011 - 21:09 — Jenny Edwards (not verified)

Rules needed to ensure fair practice from big supermarkets too. Big issur in the UK. Good luck from wine bars London Hen party London Girls nights out London champagne tea London burlesque show London Stag night London activities London portrait photography Champagne tasting classes Mothers Day tea London hen party London ideas London salsa dancer nightclubs in Brixton London wedding photography funky house DJ Clapham High Street bar London 80s nightclubs Clapham clubs Champagne tasting class London wedding photography Brixton pubs funky house DJ wine tasting class London nightlife Easter sunday club London Saturday Night Out London Bank Holiday Sunday London cocktail lesson London cocktail lessons London Notting Hill pubs Girls nights out London chocolate lessons London Soho bar Girls nights out London Dj bars London restaurants London cool London bars Hen night restaurant London London clubs London bar restaurants Cocktail making London Chrismas party london London gift vouchers London hen party activities Saturday Night Out London London cocktail bars London 70s night London cocktail lesson London portrait photographer Christmas parties Sussex 2011 Mothers Day Restaurant London... Girls nights out London Thursday Night Out London cabaret nightclub London Cocktail bar battersea cupcake lessons London 80s club Clapham High Street bar wine tasting class Cocktail lessons London Old Street bars clubs in Camden Shoreditch pubs Battersea nightclub Burlesque lesson London 70s night London Office party Essex London 70s clubs Dj bars London Easter sunday club London cupcake lessons London Frank Sinatra singer burlesque singer Bank Holiday events London London clubs burlesque clubs in London cupcake lessons London stag parties London London cocktail classes New Years Eve Club London 70s club pubs in Soho Friday Night Out London restaurants London Shoreditch bars wine tasting class Clapham pubs 80s clubs in London Christmas parties Sussex wedding photographer London Soho club Northcote road pyv burlesque performer Girls nights out London London 70s nightclubs gastro pubs London stag do ideas London Cocktail making London Oxford Street clubs Cocktail bar battersea burlesque show in London Camden pubs London portrait photographer 70s clubs London portrait photographer London Brixton bars wine tasting class cocktail bars London Afternoon tea hen party Cocktail making London Girls Night London London 70s clubs London portrait photography Xmas parties London Hen nights London burlesque club in London London cocktail lesson London gastropubs club in Soho cupcake class London Stag night London burlesque clubs London events photographer London Battersea nightclub Friday Night Out London Christmas party London 2011 London 80s nights Cocktail making London wedding DJ Surrey Burlesque Class London London sports pubs Valentine's Day Dinner London Burlesque Class London Cocktail making London Cocktail lessons London Clapham club club in Shoreditch London cocktail lesson Hen do London London 70s night Hen party London London 70s nightclubs London hen party ideas stag party activities London Afternoon tea hen party Burlesque lesson London Shared Xmas parties London London cocktail classes Burlesque lesson London cabaret night London London cabaret singer cocktail mixing London cockail bars London London 80s DJ London 80s night London cocktail class burlesque nights in London famous London pubs sports bars in London London salsa dancer clubs in Brixton 80s club cocktail class London cabaret nightclub in London London cocktail class Clapham High Street bar

My father is a farmer. And i

Fri, 09/30/2011 - 11:12 — asia (not verified)

My father is a farmer. And i want to thank you for the support you are giving to all farmers. custom doors

USDA Rules on Meatpackers

Fri, 02/18/2011 - 11:57 — Patricia Renn (not verified)

In this time of economic crisis, it's so important to allow the "little guy" to build their businesses and prosper. Don't allow the corporate conglomerates to walk over the small farmers and ranchers.

USDA's Draft Rule

Fri, 02/18/2011 - 16:01 — Jimmie Hoadley (not verified)

Improvements to the Draft Rule USDA’s draft rule needs to be improved in three areas: 1.First, and foremost, the rule does not specifically disallow purely volume-based premiums. 2.Moreover, the unreasonable preference sections focus excessively on treatment of large-volume livestock producers in relation to “groups of producers” at the expense of individual, small-volume producers. 3.Last, the draft rule fails to exclude premiums that are based on nebulous, shadowy, so-called “operational efficiencies” that packers claim occur within the confines of the plant versus real and verifiable differences in transactional costs related to procuring and handling livestock outside the plant door.

Local family farms

Thu, 02/24/2011 - 09:32 — dave b phelps (not verified)

Stop hurting the smaller farmers.

Family Farms

Sun, 02/27/2011 - 06:22 — RK Finley (not verified)

Save our family farms. Big agri is not the answer.

Save our family farms.

Fri, 06/24/2011 - 05:07 — Nathaniel B. Ingles (not verified)

It is past time to enforce the anti-trust laws dealing with big agri-business. Please level the playing field and let the family farmer have a prayer, all we want is the same considerations not preferential treatment. We need to have protectionfor the family farmers before we loose any more.

USDA Rules on Meatpackers

Wed, 06/22/2011 - 15:05 — sheila Fetzer (not verified)

Don't let corporate conglomerates Rule! There are many people trying to make difference, who really care about what's happening to this earth and those who live upon it. As a small farmer and part of the, YES WE REALLY CARE GOUP, I feel helpless at times. Its Odd that in a world changing so fast that we can't slow down enough to see that we can all make a difference. Come on government! Start backing up the people who are trying to make a difference. We'r out here and we're working hard. Show some support. We definitely need to improve these USDA rules and make it fare for the small farmer who actually cares about what's happening to the earth, making it a better place.

Maybe we could send seeds to Haiti. I have a bunch of muskmelon seeds i saved from heirloom types that were grown close enough to cross, so i cannot call them a particular variety. They trendy clothing should be kurtis great. I collection 2012 am growing bridal dresses 2012 three of the seeds party dresses 2012 this year, but haven't a crop yet.